How to Avoid Common Tourist Scams in New York City
Ever handed cash to a street magician, only to realize the real trick was making your money disappear? Knowing how to avoid common tourist scams in New York City can save you from these awkward (and expensive) moments.
Street hustles, fake tickets, and too-good-to-be-true deals happen daily. But staying alert is easier than it sounds. A few street smarts can keep your trip stress-free. So, what are the biggest scams, and how can you spot them before they catch you off guard?
1. Free CD Scam – “It’s Yours… Until It Isn’t”
Someone approaches with a “free” CD, claiming to be an up-and-coming artist. Once you take it, they demand a “donation” or payment. These days, some hand over QR codes that lead to streaming platforms with no real download. Refusing can lead to awkward pressure.
Tip: Avoid eye contact and keep your hands to yourself. Politely decline and keep walking.
2. Hot Dog Cart Overcharge – “That’ll Be… How Much?”
Grabbing a quick street dog? Vendors in tourist-heavy spots sometimes charge inflated prices if you don’t ask first. A bottle of water might jump from $2 to $5, and hot dogs can hit double digits. Instead, opt for hard working vendors or spots like Glizzy’s New York City.
Tip: Always ask for the price upfront. No menu? Walk away.
3. Fake Rideshare Pickup – “Your Uber’s Here… Or Is It?”
At airports like JFK, fake rideshare drivers target tired travelers. They may hold signs or approach offering rides, but they’re not affiliated with Uber or Lyft. Falling for it could mean an overpriced fare.
Tip: Only book through the official app and avoid anyone soliciting rides directly.
4. Times Square Costume Characters – “Say Cheese, Pay Please”
Those friendly Elmos and superheroes seem fun… until they demand cash after a photo. Some charge steep rates per character or refuse to return your phone until you pay up.
Tip: If you snap a pic, be prepared to pay. Better yet, skip it altogether.
5. Comedy Show Ticket Scam – “Tonight’s Headliner? Not Happening”
Street sellers in Times Square often pitch comedy tickets with promises of big-name acts. The catch? There’s usually a drink minimum inside, and the show rarely features the promised talent.
Tip: Book shows online or directly at the venue to avoid overpriced disappointment.
6. Fake Monks – “Bracelet for Peace… And a Price”
You might spot people dressed as monks offering free bracelets or trinkets. They’ll smile, place it on your wrist, and then ask for a donation. These aren’t real monks, and the money isn’t for charity.
Tip: Politely decline and keep walking to avoid awkward pressure.
7. Transit Fare Scam – “Just $4.75… Again?”
At busy spots like Port Authority or Penn Station, someone may approach asking for a few bucks to “get home”. They tell a convincing story, but minutes later, they’re asking someone else for the same amount.
Tip: Avoid handing out cash to strangers near transit hubs.
8. Dropped Item Scam – “Oops, You Owe Me”
Someone might bump into you and drop something—like food or glasses—then demand payment, claiming you caused it. They’ll raise their voice, hoping you’ll pay just to end the scene.
Tip: Ignore the drama and walk away. Don’t engage or make eye contact.
9. Staten Island Ferry Ticket Scam – “No Ticket Needed”
The Staten Island Ferry is free—always. Scammers near Battery Park may offer to sell you “tickets,” particularly if you mention seeing the Statue of Liberty.
Tip: Never buy tickets for the ferry. Head straight to the official terminal.
10. JFK AirTrain MetroCard Hustle – “Got a Spare Card?”
Heading to JFK via subway? Scammers may ask for your used MetroCard as you exit. They collect and resell them even though those cards don’t cover the AirTrain fare.
Tip: Keep your MetroCard or discard it properly. Don’t hand it over.
11. Too-Helpful Stranger – “Friendly… Or Fishy?”
Someone offers directions or travel advice that seems a bit too enthusiastic? Sometimes these “helpful” strangers lead you to shady spots or push you into spending money.
Tip: Rely on official apps or information centers instead of random people on the street.
12. Fake Broadway Tickets – “Front Row Seats… to Disappointment”
Outside theaters, scammers sell fake Broadway tickets at “too good to be true” prices. You risk losing money and missing the show altogether.
Tip: Buy from trusted sources like official box offices, websites, or the TKTS booth for real discounts.
13. Overpriced Souvenirs – “$30 for a Keychain?”
Vendors in touristy spots inflate prices for items like “I Love NY” shirts or Statue of Liberty trinkets. What costs $5 elsewhere might run $20 here.
Tip: Compare prices online before buying. Souvenir shops away from major attractions are often cheaper.
More…