Fancy-ish Restaurants Near Times Square for a Worthwhile Meal

Finding Fancy-ish Restaurants Near Times Square can feel like a challenge, especially in an area packed with chain restaurants, overpriced fast food, and spots that cater more to tourists than food lovers. While the neighborhood isn’t exactly known for its dining scene, that doesn’t mean you’re stuck with a basic meal. If you want something more upscale but not overly formal, there are plenty of options that strike the right balance.

What to Know Before You Go to explore Fancy-ish Restaurants Near Times Square

• Reservations Are Your Friend – Many of these restaurants book up quickly, especially before showtime. Plan ahead if you can.
• Expect Higher Prices – The area is built for tourists, so prices tend to be inflated. That said, some places offer pre-theater menus or happy hour deals.
• Crowds Are Inevitable – You’re in the heart of Midtown. If you want a quieter experience, aim for a later dinner after the Broadway rush.

Gallagher’s Steakhouse

Why we love it: This classic NYC steakhouse has been around for nearly a century, and it still delivers. The dry-aged steaks are the main event, but the old-school vibe—wood-paneled walls, tuxedoed waiters—adds to the experience. It’s a great pick for those who want a true New York steakhouse without veering into stuffy territory.

• Location: 228 W 52nd St, New York, NY 10019
• Website: gallaghersnysteakhouse.com
• Phone: 212-586-5000

The Lambs Club

Why we love it: Housed in a historic building, The Lambs Club offers a sleek but cozy setting, complete with a fireplace and Art Deco decor. The menu leans toward upscale American cuisine, with standout dishes like the filet mignon and lobster bisque. Bonus points for an extensive cocktail list.

• Location: 132 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
• Website: thelambsclub.com
• Phone: 212-997-5262

Le Bernardin

Why we love it: If you’re looking to splurge, Le Bernardin is one of the most celebrated seafood restaurants in the country. Chef Eric Ripert’s menu is refined yet approachable, with dishes like the thinly pounded yellowfin tuna and the signature Dover sole. It’s Michelin-star dining but without unnecessary fuss.

•  Location: 155 W 51st St, New York, NY 10019
• Website: le-bernardin.com
• Phone: 212-554-1515

Hunt & Fish Club

Why we love it: Dim lighting, plush leather booths, and a menu stacked with steakhouse classics make this a solid pick for a fancier night out. The prime cuts of beef are the main attraction, but don’t skip the seafood tower if you’re dining with a group.

•  Location: 125 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
•  Website: Hunt & Fish Club
• Phone: 347-625-1220

Charlie Palmer Steak NYC

Why we love it: A more modern take on the traditional steakhouse, Charlie Palmer Steak serves up premium cuts with an emphasis on seasonal ingredients. The sleek design and excellent service make it a great option for both business dinners and date nights.

• Location: 6 Times Square, 4th Floor, The Knickerbocker Hotel, New York, NY 10036
•  Website: charliepalmersteak.com
• Phone:212-319-1660

Osteria al Doge

Why we love it: A cozy Italian spot that feels worlds away from the chaos of Times Square. The handmade pasta, fresh seafood, and warm ambiance make it a perfect choice for those who want something a little more intimate without losing that upscale feel.

•  Location:142 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036
• Website: osteriaaldoge.com
• Phone:212-944-3643

Sushi Yasuda

Why we love it: If you’re in the mood for sushi that goes beyond the standard spicy tuna roll, Sushi Yasuda is a must. The omakase experience is a standout, with expertly crafted nigiri that lets the high-quality fish shine.

• Location: 675 E 43rd St, Manhattan, NY 10017
•  Website: sushiyasuda.com
• Phone: 212-972-1001

The Modern

Why we love it: Located inside the Museum of Modern Art, this sleek, contemporary restaurant offers Michelin-starred dining in a stylish setting. The tasting menu is the way to go if you’re up for a splurge, but the bar area also serves a la carte dishes in a more relaxed atmosphere.