The Best Pizza Spots in New York City – Ranked by a Local
New York City and pizza? They go together like late nights and dollar slices. But with so many options, finding the right one can feel like an impossible task. That’s where I come in. As someone who’s spent way too much time (and money) searching for the best pies, I’ve got strong opinions. This isn’t some tourist-friendly list—it’s the real deal, straight from a local who knows what’s worth the hype. So if you’re looking for the best pizza spots in New York City – ranked by a local, you’re in the right place.
Expect a mix of classic slices, no-frills joints, and legendary pies that deserve the attention. No fluff. Just good pizza.
Best Pizza in New York City: Top Picks from a Local | New York City Pizza Guide
Bleecker Street Pizza
A go-to spot for a slice that never disappoints. Known for its Nona Marie Pie, this place has been voted one of New York City’s best for years. The secret? A family recipe that balances crispy crust, rich sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. If you’re stopping in for a quick bite or grabbing a whole pie, this is a solid pick.
- Website: https://bleeckerstreetpizza.com
- Location: 69 7th Ave S, New York
- Phone: 1 212-924-4466
NY Pizza Suprema
This shop has been serving pizza since 1964, and its reputation has only grown. The slices are big, the crust is crispy, and the sauce has that perfect tangy-sweet balance. It’s a favorite for locals and tourists alike, proving that sometimes, keeping it simple is the best way to go.
- Price Range: $ – $$
- Website: https://nypizzasuprema.com
- Location: 413 8th Ave, New York
- Phone: 1 212-594-8939
Sottocasa Pizzeria Harlem
Neapolitan pizza is done the right way. They use Italian flour and tomatoes but source their fresh cheeses from the U.S. to keep everything as fresh as possible. The wood-fired oven gives every pie that slightly charred crust and soft, chewy center that fans of Neapolitan pizza love.
- Price Range: $$
- Website: https://harlem.sottocasanyc.com
- Location: 227 Malcolm X Blvd, New York
- Phone: 1 646-928-4870
Grand Street Pizza
A neighborhood spot that serves up classic NY-style pizza alongside a well-curated beer and wine selection. The setting is more elevated than your average slice joint, making it a great place to sit down and enjoy a pie with friends.
- Price Range: $$
- Website: www.grandstreetpizza.com
- Location: 384 Grand St, New York
- Phone: 1 646-918-6194
L’Antica Pizzeria Da Michele
This spot brings a taste of Naples to New York City. The pizzas stick to tradition, with a thin, blistered crust and simple yet flavorful toppings. While the Margherita is the star of the menu, they also serve fresh pasta and seafood for those looking for something more.
- Price Range: $$
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: https://damicheleusa.com/nyc
- Location: 2 Bank St, New York
- Phone: 1 929-524-6682
Kesté Pizza e Vino
Founded by Chef Roberto Caporuscio, this small but mighty spot has been serving Neapolitan wood-fired pizzas since 1999. The menu also includes vegan and gluten-free options, making it a good choice for a range of diets.
- Price Range: $$
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: https://kestepizzeria.com
- Location: 77 Fulton St, New York
- Phone: 1 212-243-1500
Nuovo York Pizza
A newer name in the New York City pizza scene, but one that has quickly gained fans. Every pizza is made with high-quality ingredients and attention to detail. From a classic Margherita to more loaded options, there’s something for every type of pizza lover here.
- Price Range: $ – $$
- Website: www.nuovoyorkpizza.com
- Location: 105 E 9th St, New York
- Phone: 1 646-476-2428
Joe’s Pizza Broadway
Joe’s is one of those places that’s just as popular with tourists as it is with locals—and for good reason. The no-frills, classic NY slice is exactly what you want when you’re craving a quick and satisfying bite.
- Price Range: $$ – $$$
- Website: www.joespizzanyc.com
- Location: 1435 Broadway, New York
- Phone: 1 646-559-4878
Rubirosa
A favorite for those who love thin-crust pizza. The recipe has been in the family since the 1960s, and it’s easy to see why people keep coming back. They also have an extensive gluten-free menu, making it a great option for those with dietary restrictions.
- Price Range: $$
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: www.rubirosanyc.com
- Location: 235 Mulberry St, New York
- Phone: 1 212-965-0500
Vezzo New York City Thin Crust Pizza
If you like your pizza extra thin and crispy, Vezzo is the place to go. Located in Murray Hill, this spot has built a cult following for its impossibly thin-crust pies. The menu is loaded with toppings, so you can keep it simple or go all out.
- Price Range: $$
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: www.nycthincrust.com
- Location: 178 Lexington Ave, New York
- Phone: 1 212-839-8300
Don Antonio
This Hell’s Kitchen staple is known for its Neapolitan-style pizza and pizze fritte (lightly fried pizza). The Montanara, a fried-and-then-baked pizza, is a must-try. Add a wide selection of Italian craft beers and cocktails, and you’ve got a solid Midtown pizza stop.
- Price Range: $$
- Website: www.donantoniopizza.com
- Location: 309 W 50th St, New York
- Phone: 1 646-719-1043
More…