Best NYC Foods You Need to Try If you’re Traveling to New York This 2025
Okay, so, you’re planning a trip to New York in 2025? Great choice! But let’s be real, navigating the food scene can be a bit… intense. You don’t want to waste a single meal, right? We all know the classic New York eats, but trust me, things are changing. To keep you from missing out, let’s talk about the best NYC foods you need to try. We will skip the tourist traps and get to the good stuff. Think of it as your food map, but way more fun.
Must-Try Foods in New York City – Best Eats Across New York City
Giant Reese’s Cup (Hershey’s Chocolate World)
Customize your one-pound peanut butter cup with a variety of mix-ins for an extra-rich treat.
- Website: www.chocolateworld.com
- Location: 20 Times Square, 701 7th Ave, New York
- Phone: 1 212-581-9100
Chicken Nuggets with Caviar Truffle and Fried Chicken (COQODAQ)
These aren’t your typical nuggets. Clean-fried for a crispy bite without the grease, they pair rich truffle notes with golden crunch.
- Price Range: $$ – $$$
- Reservation: Book here.
- Website: www.coqodaq.com
- Location: 12 E 22nd St, New York
- Phone: 1 646-490-5099
Bagels and Cream Cheese (PopUp Bagels)
Freshly baked, warm, and perfectly textured, these bagels come with rich, creamy spreads that hit the spot.
- Price Range: $$
- Website: www.popupbagels.com
- Location: 177 Thompson St, New York
- Phone: 1 203-297-8819
Burger and Fries (7th Street Burger Times Square)
Simple yet flavorful, these burgers pair perfectly with crispy fries and a spicy sauce for extra kick.
- Price Range: $$
- Website: https://7thstreetburger.com
- Location: 485 7th Ave, New York
- Phone: 1 646-224-6919
S’mores Hot Chocolate (Glace New York City)
Rich and creamy, this drink offers warmth and sweetness in every sip.
- Price Range: $$
- Website: https://glaceny.com
- Location: 1266 Madison Ave, New York
- Phone: 1 347-502-6445
Cinnamon Rolls (Sunday Morning NYC)
With rotating flavors like ube macapuno and pistachio mascarpone, these rolls are a sweet way to start your day.
- Instagram: @sundaymorningcinnamonrolls
- Location: 29 Avenue B New York
- Phone: (786) 553-6409
Pancake (Bubby’s)
Fluffy and served all day, these pancakes bring a comforting start to your morning—or a late-night treat.
- Price Range: $$
- Reservation: Book here.
- Website: www.bubbys.com
- Location: 120 Hudson St, New York
- Phone: 1 212-219-0666
Taco (LOS TACOS No.1)
Made with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes, these tacos bring authentic Mexican flavors to the city.
- Price Range: $
- Website: www.lostacos1.com
- Location: 229 W 43rd St, New York
Italian Sandwich (All’Antico Vinaio)
Tuscan meats, cheeses, and freshly baked bread create sandwiches worth lining up for.
- Price Range: $$
- Website: www.allanticovinaiousa.com
- Location: 729 8th Ave, New York
- Phone: 1 917-970-0033
Bagel (Apollo Bagels)
Offering plain, everything, and sesame varieties, Apollo serves bagels topped with smoked salmon, tomato, and other fresh ingredients.
- Price Range: $ – $$
- Website: www.apollobagels.com
- Location: 242 E 10th St, New York
- Phone: 1 844-218-3081
Chocolate Chip Cookies (Culture Espresso)
Baked fresh daily, these cookies are soft, gooey, and pair perfectly with a hot cup of coffee.
- Price Range: $ – $$
- Website: www.cultureespresso.com
- Location: 247 W 36th St., New York
- Phone: 1 646-438-9555
Jalapeno Cheddar Bagel (Liberty Bagels)
Add a bit of heat to your morning with this cheesy, spicy option. Pair it with bacon, eggs, and cream cheese for a hearty meal.
- Price Range: $$
- Website: https://libertybagels.com
- Location: 260 W 35th St, New York
- Phone: 1 212-279-1124
Double Cheeseburger with Bacon and Egg (Au Cheval)
Thick-cut bacon, juicy patties, and melted cheese come together for a burger that’s hard to resist.
- Price Range: $$
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: www.auchevaldiner.com
- Location: 33 Cortlandt Alley, New York
- Phone: 1 646-350-2429
Truffle Pasta (Fiaschetteria “Pistoia”)
Generous amounts of fresh truffle elevate this comforting pasta dish, making it rich without being heavy.
- Price Range: $$
- Reservation: Book here.
- Website: www.fiaschetteriapistoia.com
- Location: 647 E 11th St, New York
- Phone: 1 212-777-3355
Burrata Pizza (L’Industrie Pizzeria)
This slice combines creamy burrata, fresh basil, and a perfectly crispy crust for a satisfying bite.
- Price Range: $$
- Website: www.lindustriebk.com
- Location: 254 S 2nd St, Brooklyn, NY
- Phone: 1 718-599-0002
Square Pizza Slices, Cheesesteak and Chicken Cutlet Ala Vodka (Mama’s TOO!)
Known for their crispy square slices and rich toppings, Mama’s TOO! offers hearty, flavorful options for quick meals.
- Price Range: $$
- Website: www.mamastoo.com
- Location: 2750 Broadway, New York
- Phone: 1 212-510-7256
Pretzel Bun Double Cheeseburger (Emily)
With soft pretzel buns, double-stacked beef patties, and tangy sauce, this burger delivers on flavor and texture.
- Price Range: $$
- Reservation: Click here.
- Website: www.pizzalovesemily.com
- Location: 919 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY
- Phone: 1 347-844-9588
More…