10+ Best Irish Restaurants in New York City for Authentic Eats

Sezim Duishenbieva
· · · ·

Irish pubs and restaurants in New York City offer more than just great food. They bring together traditional flavors with fresh ideas in a fun and welcoming setting. If you’re in the mood for a hearty Irish stew or a new take on shepherd’s pie, these spots serve up rich flavors with an inviting atmosphere. From neighborhood pubs to modern Irish kitchens, here’s where to find the best Irish food in the city.

Modern Twists at Top Irish Eateries in New York

The Dead Rabbit

Interior of a traditional Irish pub with a bar lined with stools, decorated with an extensive array of photographs and memorabilia covering the ceiling and walls, showcasing a rustic wooden aesthetic and a well-stocked bar displaying various bottles and daily specials.
via drinksology

Located in the Financial District, The Dead Rabbit brings together the essence of an Irish pub with the hustle and bustle of New York City. This spot is famous for its Irish breakfast and traditional Sunday roasts, all served in an environment filled with antique decor and a sense of history. Regulars and newcomers alike flock here for the exceptional brunch and the engaging, lively setting that’s always buzzing with energy.

Location: 30 Water St, New York, NY 10004, United States
Type of Cuisine: Irish
Menu Highlights: Irish breakfast, classic Sunday roast
Google Reviews: Renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and excellent brunch offerings.
Website: The Dead Rabbit

McSorley’s Old Ale House

A bartender in a traditional Irish pub, surrounded by an eclectic collection of memorabilia and vintage decor, serves pints of beer. The setting is richly decorated with historical artifacts and photographs, creating a nostalgic and inviting atmosphere.
via businessinsider

As one of the oldest Irish pubs in New York City, located in the East Village, McSorley’s offers a dive into history with its choice of only two ales: light or dark. The interior, complete with historical artifacts and old photographs, provides a backdrop that feels like a journey to another era. Its menu, featuring simple yet satisfying fare like cheese and crackers, complements the traditional pub experience.

Location: 15 E 7th St, New York, NY 10003, United States
Type of Cuisine: Irish-American
Menu Highlights: McSorley’s Dark Ale, cheese and crackers plate
Google Reviews: Praised for preserving the look and feel of a traditional Irish pub.
Website: McSorley’s Old Ale House

Donovan’s Pub

Interior Donovan's Pub
via nyctourism

In the heart of Woodside, Donovan’s Pub is renowned for its straightforward, delicious Irish cuisine, including its signature corned beef and cabbage, and highly praised burgers. The pub’s relaxing and friendly atmosphere makes it a favored spot for both families and friends looking for a comforting meal in a place that feels like home.

  • Exact Location: 57-24 Roosevelt Avenue, Woodside, NY 11377
  • Type of Cuisine: Irish
  • Menu Highlights: Corned beef and cabbage, renowned burgers
  • Google Reviews: Celebrated for its cozy feel and comfort food.
  • Website: Donovan’s Pub

The Irish American Pub

The Irish American Pub
via twimg

This pub, located close to the Financial District, is a favorite for its welcoming vibe and comprehensive selection of beers. It’s an ideal place for casual meet-ups, offering a variety of tasty dishes like chicken wings. The location also makes it a convenient choice for after-work drinks and social gatherings.

  • Exact Location: 17 John Street, New York, NY 10038
  • Type of Cuisine: Irish
  • Menu Highlights: Chicken wings, extensive beer selection
  • Google Reviews: Favored for its friendly service and great location.
  • Website: The Irish American Pub

Connolly’s Pub & Restaurant

Interior view of an ornate Irish pub featuring a well-lit bar lined with various taps and a wide selection of spirits. The bar is adorned with Irish and Guinness-related memorabilia, including plaques and banners, enhancing the traditional vibe. Stools are arranged neatly, inviting guests to enjoy a drink in this classic setting.
via connollyspubandrestaurant

Connolly’s, with its various Midtown locations, is perfect for anyone looking to enjoy traditional Irish dishes in a vibrant setting. It’s particularly noted for its hearty Irish breakfasts and savory beef and Guinness pies. The atmosphere is always friendly and animated, making it a popular destination for both lunch and evening outings.

Location: Multiple locations including Midtown
Type of Cuisine: Irish
Menu Highlights: Irish breakfast, beef and Guinness pie
Google Reviews: Loved for its authentic vibe and friendly service.
Website: Connolly’s Pub & Restaurant

The Wheeltapper Pub

Exterior night view of The Wheeltapper Pub, showcasing its distinctive teal and dark blue façade with the pub's name illuminated in elegant script above the entrance. The welcoming, traditional design hints at a classic Irish pub atmosphere inside.
via tripadvisor

Situated in Midtown East, The Wheeltapper Pub is celebrated for its classic Irish dishes served in a genuinely warm setting. The outdoor patio area is a highlight, offering a pleasant retreat from the city’s frenzy. It’s a great spot for enjoying rich, flavorful dishes like Guinness beef stew and traditional fish and chips.

Location: Between Lexington &, 141 E 44th St, 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10017, United States
Type of Cuisine: Irish
Menu Highlights: Guinness beef stew, crispy fish and chips
Google Reviews: Known for its inviting patio and substantial Irish meals.
Website: The Wheeltapper Pub

The Irish Exit

Located in Midtown, The Irish Exit is known for its inventive take on Irish-American cuisine, featuring items like Guinness beef sliders and Irish nachos. The bar is always lively, filled with a mix of locals and tourists enjoying the creative menu and vibrant nightlife.

Location: 421 8th Ave, New York, NY 10001, United States
Type of Cuisine: Modern Irish-American
Menu Highlights: Guinness beef sliders, Irish nachos
Google Reviews: Popular for its energetic bar scene and creative cuisine.
Website: The Irish Exit

Interior view of The Irish Exit pub, featuring a modern and spacious bar area with stylish wooden furniture and vibrant lighting. The bar displays a vast selection of drinks beneath illuminated signs and digital displays promoting Irish-themed events and specials, creating a lively and inviting atmosphere for guests.
via partyslate

Molly’s Pub and Shebeen

Interior Molly’s Pub and Shebeen
via mollysshebeennyc

Molly’s, found in Gramercy Park, is one of the city’s most authentic Irish pubs, complete with a rustic thatched roof and a cozy fireplace. It’s a favorite for its classic dishes like Shepherd’s pie and fish and chips, served in an environment that transports guests straight to Ireland.

  • Exact Location: 287 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10010
  • Type of Cuisine: Irish
  • Menu Highlights: Shepherd’s pie, fish and chips
  • Google Reviews: Known for its authentic Irish pub atmosphere and thatched roof.
  • Website: Molly’s Shebeen

The Wren

The Wren Irish Restaurant
via tripadvisor

On Bowery, The Wren offers a modern interpretation of Irish pub cuisine, with upscale versions of pub classics. The atmosphere is stylish yet welcoming, making it a perfect place for a chic dinner or a lively night out with innovative cocktails and refined dishes.

  • Exact Location: 344 Bowery, New York, NY 10012
  • Type of Cuisine: Irish
  • Menu Highlights: Upscale pub classics
  • Google Reviews: Appreciated for its modern take on traditional dishes and vibrant bar scene.
  • Website: The Wren

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *