Best Candy Shops in New York State for a Sweet Adventure

Julie Anne L.
· · · ·

Got a sweet tooth that just won’t quit? You’re not alone. New York State is sprinkled with spots where candy isn’t just a treat—it’s an experience. From colorful walls packed with classic sweets to shelves filled with quirky confections, there’s always something that sparks nostalgia or curiosity. This guide to the best candy shops in New York State for a sweet adventure takes you through places where every visit feels like stepping into a sugary wonderland.

Where to Find the Best Candy Shops in New York State

M&M’s New York

Photo via @mmschocolate and @dovechocolate / Instagram

Right in the heart of Broadway, M&M’s Times Square is a two-story playground for candy lovers. Imagine standing before a massive color wall filled with thousands of Milk, Peanut, and Specialty M&M’S.

If you’re curious about which M&M character you resemble, the interactive InnerM analyzer adds a playful twist. Since 2012, visitors have enjoyed personalizing their candy and printing custom messages and images on M&M’s in just minutes. With a rainbow of 15 colors to choose from, it’s a treat tailored to you.

  • Website: www.mms.com 
  • Location: 1600 Broadway, New York
  • Phone: 1 212-295-3857

Economy Candy

Visit Economy Candy, New York City’s oldest candy store, where shelves are packed with over 2,000 sweet selections. From Abba Zaba to Zagnut bars, this spot is a treasure trove of old-school favorites and hard-to-find goodies. Locals and visitors flock here for chocolate-covered graham crackers, bags of gummies, and retro treats that spark childhood memories.

IT’SUGAR Times Square

Photo via @itsugar / Instagram

At IT’SUGAR Times Square, candy meets pop culture with a splash of humor. Spread across three floors and 24,000 square feet, this candy department store isn’t just about sweets—it’s about having fun. Known for their quirky creations and oversized treats, IT’SUGAR encourages you to embrace a carefree moment surrounded by vibrant displays and familiar brands.

BonBon – A Swedish Candy Co.

Craving something from across the pond? BonBon brings Swedish sweets to the streets of New York City. With a carefully selected mix of gummies, licorice, and chocolates, this shop offers a taste of Scandinavia. Each piece is thoughtfully chosen to satisfy your sweet cravings while introducing you to new flavors.

The Sweet Shop NYC

Photo via @thesweetshopnyc / Instagram

The Sweet Shop NYC feels like stepping into a time machine with its shelves of retro candies and handcrafted chocolates. Fresh-baked cookies and handmade ice creams from local makers add to the appeal. If you’re searching for that long-lost candy from your childhood, there’s a good chance you’ll find it here.

Eugene J. Candy Co.

Photo via @eugenejcandyco) • Instagram

Halloween lovers rejoice at Eugene J. Candy Co. This spooky-themed candy store keeps the festive spirit alive all year. Think quirky confections, creative candy designs, and a playful environment that brings a touch of October to every visit.

  • Website: www.eugenej.com 
  • Location: 16 Wilson Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  • Phone: 1 718-381-1050

Williams Candy Shop

Photo via @factorycandy / Instagram

Right near the famous boardwalk, Williams Candy Shop serves up nostalgic treats like caramel apples, cotton candy, and fresh fudge. With its old-fashioned charm, this veteran confectioner knows how to keep traditions alive, one sweet bite at a time.

  • Instagram: @williamscandy1
  • Location: 1318 Surf Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  • Phone: 1 718-372-0302

Dylan’s Candy Bar

Photo via @dylanscandybar / Instagram

Founded in 2001, Dylan’s Candy Bar blends candy with fashion and art, creating an engaging space for candy enthusiasts of all ages. Housing over 7,000 confections from around the world, it’s a colorful wonderland that sparks creativity while satisfying your sweet cravings.

Sugarfina

For those seeking something upscale, Sugarfina offers an array of gourmet candies, beautifully packaged for gifting (or treating yourself). Signature sweets like Champagne Bears® and Peach Bellini® gummies cater to adult tastes, proving candy isn’t just for kids.

  • Website: www.sugarfina.com 
  • Location: World Trade Center, 10007, 70 Vesey St, New York
  • Phone: 1 646-630-8139

Myzel’s Chocolate

Photo via @myzelschocolate / Instagram

A family-run shop with a deep-rooted European tradition, Myzel’s Chocolate is known for handcrafted cookies and rich, decadent chocolates. Recipes passed down through generations ensure every bite is steeped in both history and flavor.

  • Website: www.myzels.com 
  • Location: 140 W 55th St # 1, New York
  • Phone: 1 212-245-4233

Hershey’s Chocolate World

Photo via @imkarenrivera / Instagram

Enter Hershey’s Chocolate World, where the aroma of chocolate fills the air. Guests can sip creamy milkshakes, create customized candy bars, or pick up giant-sized treats. It’s a sensory experience for anyone who loves Hershey’s iconic sweets.

Andy’s Candy Tree

Photo via @andyscandytree / Instagram

Andy’s Candy Tree is more than just candy—it’s a family-owned gift shop filled with international sweets, stickers, and specialty gift items. Their signature mystery candy boxes add an element of surprise for anyone looking for a sweet treat with a twist.

Fferins of Brooklyn

Photo via @theother5th / Instagram

With shelves stocked with British chocolates, nostalgic sweets, and a vast pick-and-mix selection, Fferins of Brooklyn has something for everyone. Can’t find what you’re looking for? The friendly staff is happy to help track down your favorite candy.

  • Instagram: @fferins_bk
  • Location: 438 7th Ave, Brooklyn, NY
  • Phone: 1 718-788-5788

Sugar Bear Candy Store

Photo via @sugarbearcandystore / Instagram

At Sugar Bear Candy Store, variety is the name of the game. From freeze-dried goodies to spicy chili chamoy treats, they cater to every craving. This shop aims to do more than just sell candy—it’s about creating moments of happiness with every visit.

Stick With Me

Photo via @swmsweets / Instagram

Since 2014, Stick With Me Sweets has been crafting delicate bonbons, soft caramels, and seasonal truffles. Their beautifully wrapped confections make thoughtful gifts, perfect for celebrating special occasions or just brightening someone’s day.

See’s Candies

Photo via @mcconnellsicecreams and @seescandies / Instagram

For classic American sweets, See’s Candies is a reliable choice. Known for boxed chocolates, lollipops, and peanut brittle, this store focuses on quality and friendly service. While the New York location may have a smaller selection, their timeless favorites remain available.

Sweeties Candy Cottage

Photo via @girliesgrubs / Instagram

Bright and colorful, Sweeties Candy Cottage has been a Long Island staple for three decades. With shelves full of nostalgic treats, viral TikTok candies, and handcrafted chocolates, it’s a spot that welcomes all ages. Their expansive Swedish candy collection is a bonus for anyone looking to try something new.

Schmidt’s Candy

Photo via @schmidtscandy / Instagram

Since 1925, Schmidt’s Candy has been using traditional German recipes to produce old-fashioned confections. Hand-dipped chocolates and caramel creations reflect a dedication to time-honored methods and flavors.

Roni-Sue’s Chocolates

Photo via @jamesandkarla / Instagram

At Roni-Sue’s Chocolates, creativity meets quality. Beyond delicious truffles and rich hot chocolate, they offer hands-on classes where you can learn to make your own sweets. It’s a personal way to connect with the world of candy making.

  • Website: www.roni-sue.com 
  • Location: 148 Forsyth St, New York
  • Phone: 1 212-677-1216

Parkside Candy

Photo via @cameron_gray / Instagram

A fixture in Buffalo since 1927, Parkside Candy combines an old-fashioned ice cream parlor with a candy store. Their signature Sponge Candy is a local favorite, drawing both locals and visitors seeking a taste of Buffalo’s sweet traditions.

More…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *