How to Spot a True New Yorker: 10 Signs You’re Dealing with a Local
If you’ve spent time in New York City, you’ve probably noticed that the locals have a rhythm, a way of moving through life that feels different from any other place. So, how can you tell if someone is a local? There are a few true New Yorker signs you’ll see right away. Whether it’s their subway expertise or their no-nonsense attitude, here are 10 unmistakable signs you’re dealing with a true New Yorker.
True New Yorker Signs: How to Spot a Local
1. They Walk Like They Have Somewhere to Be
There’s no dawdling in New York City. If you’re walking like you’re on vacation, taking in the sights and sounds, you’re probably not a local. Real New Yorkers move with purpose, weaving through crowds, avoiding obstacles, and getting from point A to point B as efficiently as possible. Whether they’re late for a meeting or just grabbing lunch, you won’t see a New Yorker standing still in the middle of the sidewalk—except maybe to check their phone for a second.
2. The Subway is Their Second Home
If you’re navigating the subway like it’s a maze, you’re still a tourist. A true New Yorker? They’re gliding through the turnstiles, already knowing which train they need, and adjusting their routine without even blinking. They know how to deal with delays, crowded trains, and can navigate through multiple transfers with ease. They’ve perfected the art of making a train just in time, too—because you know, the subway waits for no one.
3. Times Square is Not for Them
Yes, Times Square is a must-see for tourists, but for New Yorkers, it’s the equivalent of the tourist trap that you try to avoid at all costs. A local knows better than to spend more time than necessary around all those flashing lights and crowds. They’ll tell you that the heart of the city beats far beyond this over-hyped area, in quieter neighborhoods, and hidden spots that most tourists miss.
4. They Don’t Do Street Names—They Do Cross Streets
A true New Yorker doesn’t care about a street address, they care about where two streets meet. “Just head down to 34th and 5th, and it’s right there,” they’ll say. Get used to hearing street intersections as directions, because that’s the real New York way of navigating. It’s also a quicker way of communicating a complicated street name you’ll forget the second you turn the corner.
5. They Have a Bodega Ritual
The bodega is like the neighborhood corner store, but for New Yorkers, it’s way more than that. Locals have a special relationship with their neighborhood bodega, popping in for everything from coffee in the morning to late-night snacks. They know the best time to go in to avoid the lines, and what to order for an efficient, quick stop. Bonus points if they’re on a first-name basis with the owner or cashier.
6. They Will Know How to Cross the Street
If you’ve spent time in NYC, you’ll quickly learn that traffic laws don’t always apply. A true New Yorker doesn’t wait for the light to change if there’s no car in sight. They assess the situation, take a quick look, and cross when it feels safe. Jaywalking is practically an art form in New York, and locals do it like they’ve been doing it forever.
7. Pizza Is a Way of Life
Pizza is to New Yorkers what coffee is to the rest of us. It’s a meal, a snack, and sometimes, it’s even dinner. But a true New Yorker will tell you that there’s only one spot for pizza, and it’s probably a hole-in-the-wall place you’ve never heard of. The loyalty to a favorite pizzeria is unmatched—no, no, that slice from the place on the corner is nothing compared to the one at that spot on the block. These are the true New Yorker signs: knowing where to find the best slice and sticking to the local pizzerias that give the city its authentic flavor.
8. They Don’t Need GPS
Google Maps? Not for a local. A real New Yorker knows how to get almost anywhere by just reading the streets and landmarks. They understand that the city grid system isn’t too complicated, but it’s also about being tuned into the rhythm of the city—knowing which blocks to cut through, and which ones to avoid. No detours needed when you’ve got New York instincts.
9. They Balance Directness with a Subtle Kindness
New Yorkers have a reputation for being blunt or straight to the point, but there’s a quiet understanding beneath it. They’ll cut through small talk to get to the heart of the matter, but they also know how to be considerate when it counts. It’s a blend of honest, no-nonsense communication paired with a surprising amount of empathy. You’ll feel that in the way they check on you if you’re running late, or how they hold the door open even when they’re rushing out of the subway.
10. They’ve Accepted the Weather (Even When It’s Awful)
New York weather is as unpredictable as the subway system, but true locals don’t let it bother them. Whether it’s a snowstorm in the middle of winter or a heatwave in summer, they’ve learned to deal. Sure, they might grumble about it, but they wouldn’t trade the changing seasons for anything. It’s just part of living here, and they roll with it.
Being a true New Yorker isn’t just about knowing the subway routes or avoiding Times Square—it’s about living in the city’s rhythm, embracing its fast pace, and understanding the little things that make the city feel like home. Whether you spot them walking with purpose or navigating a conversation with precision, a real New Yorker is more than just someone who lives here. They are the ones who make this city tick. How many of these signs did you spot in yourself or someone you know?
If you’re new to New York and want to explore the city from a different perspective, check out our guide on NYC’s Ferry System: A Guide for Newcomers to discover another quintessential New York experience.
More…